TD Help or Interference?
At the end of a long tourament game, it was clock-banging time. Both contestants were aiming to win via a flag fall, or a fast checkmate: tick, tick, tick. Pawns did their best foot-soldier impression and raced to reach the opposite side of the board. Their aim was simply to become royalty — to become a queen. Then fate intervened.
Your pawn was a lot closer to gaining a throne than your opponent’s. Then it happened. Your lonely pawn reached its destination. The promotion ceremony only needed a queen for the regal swap. Her majesty was available to you if you stretched out in a semi-seated, semi-standing position to reach her. Her majesty was hastily nabbed by your nervous fingers. The queen’s journey towards the playing field was on … until you bumped the edge of the table. The queen went flying down to the floor only to roll, roll, roll into infinity.
The TD watching the contest stopped the game timer to help you locate the missing empress. Our chess official had noticed where the rolling queen had hidden herself. It was a quick trip right back to your hand. With the clock running again the game continued. Her majesty delivered mate in short order.
The opponent claimed that the TD had interfered in the game. Did they?
TJ Says: In this instance, the promoted piece dropping to the floor while hiding in plain sight creates a missing piece. By understanding the idea behind rule 8F7 (Promoted piece not available) it is clear the clocks should be halted and the piece (the queen in this case) retrieved. In practice, many TDs carry extra queens with them for just such goofy times. TDs are encouraged to have the result of the game take place on the board and ignore any attempts to twist a rule’s words to create a loophole. The TD did not interfere.
Pairing Error Fix?
Inadvertent inequities creep into the pairings. During Round 1, an unnoticed pairing miscue appeared. Sometimes data just goes astray, even with pairings software. Misinformation is entered and inferior pairings go out. Sadly, flawed data sometimes goes undiscovered until the game is over. If you are the one that suffered through a mismatch in a game, bring it to the TD’s attention. Please don’t wait until well after your contest has ended. The TD will correct the data for future pairings.
A few rounds later, you may see a way for the TD to make pairings that benefit you. The matchups you propose would not follow the standard Swiss formula(s) for making pairings; however, your suggested pairings would make up for the earlier error. This time the error would be in your favor. Should the TD accept your suggestion?
TJ Says: The TD should reject your idea. While you would benefit from the skewing of the Swiss pairings in your favor, other contests will then fall short of their due matchups, creating their own version of unfair pairings.
Want more? Past columns can be found here or by searching the Chess Life Online archives.
Plus, listen to Tim when he was a guest on the podcasts “One Move at a Time” and “The Chess Angle.”
Tim Just is a National Tournament Director, FIDE National Arbiter, and editor of the 5th, 6th, and 7th editions of the US Chess Rulebook. He is also the author of My Opponent is Eating a Doughnut & Just Law, which are both available from US Chess Sales and Amazon/Kindle. Additionally, Tim revised The Guide To Scholastic Chess, a guide created to help teachers and scholastic organizers who wish to begin, improve, or strengthen their school chess program. US Chess awarded the 2022 Tournament Director Lifetime Achievement Award to Tim. He is also a member of the US Chess Rules Committee plus the Tournament Director Certification Committee (TDCC). His new column, exclusive to US Chess, “Just the Rules” will help clarify potentially confusing regulations.
Categories
Archives
- August 2025 (6)
- July 2025 (43)
- June 2025 (25)
- May 2025 (24)
- April 2025 (29)
- March 2025 (29)
- February 2025 (20)
- January 2025 (24)
- December 2024 (34)
- November 2024 (18)
- October 2024 (35)
- September 2024 (23)
- August 2024 (27)
- July 2024 (44)
- June 2024 (27)
- May 2024 (31)
- April 2024 (51)
- March 2024 (34)
- February 2024 (25)
- January 2024 (26)
- December 2023 (29)
- November 2023 (26)
- October 2023 (37)
- September 2023 (27)
- August 2023 (37)
- July 2023 (47)
- June 2023 (33)
- May 2023 (37)
- April 2023 (45)
- March 2023 (37)
- February 2023 (28)
- January 2023 (31)
- December 2022 (23)
- November 2022 (32)
- October 2022 (31)
- September 2022 (19)
- August 2022 (39)
- July 2022 (32)
- June 2022 (35)
- May 2022 (21)
- April 2022 (31)
- March 2022 (33)
- February 2022 (21)
- January 2022 (27)
- December 2021 (36)
- November 2021 (34)
- October 2021 (25)
- September 2021 (25)
- August 2021 (41)
- July 2021 (36)
- June 2021 (29)
- May 2021 (29)
- April 2021 (31)
- March 2021 (33)
- February 2021 (28)
- January 2021 (29)
- December 2020 (38)
- November 2020 (40)
- October 2020 (41)
- September 2020 (35)
- August 2020 (38)
- July 2020 (36)
- June 2020 (46)
- May 2020 (42)
- April 2020 (37)
- March 2020 (60)
- February 2020 (38)
- January 2020 (45)
- December 2019 (35)
- November 2019 (35)
- October 2019 (42)
- September 2019 (45)
- August 2019 (56)
- July 2019 (44)
- June 2019 (35)
- May 2019 (40)
- April 2019 (48)
- March 2019 (61)
- February 2019 (39)
- January 2019 (30)
- December 2018 (29)
- November 2018 (51)
- October 2018 (45)
- September 2018 (29)
- August 2018 (49)
- July 2018 (35)
- June 2018 (31)
- May 2018 (39)
- April 2018 (31)
- March 2018 (26)
- February 2018 (33)
- January 2018 (30)
- December 2017 (26)
- November 2017 (24)
- October 2017 (30)
- September 2017 (30)
- August 2017 (32)
- July 2017 (27)
- June 2017 (32)
- May 2017 (26)
- April 2017 (37)
- March 2017 (28)
- February 2017 (30)
- January 2017 (27)
- December 2016 (29)
- November 2016 (24)
- October 2016 (32)
- September 2016 (31)
- August 2016 (27)
- July 2016 (24)
- June 2016 (26)
- May 2016 (19)
- April 2016 (30)
- March 2016 (37)
- February 2016 (27)
- January 2016 (33)
- December 2015 (25)
- November 2015 (23)
- October 2015 (16)
- September 2015 (28)
- August 2015 (28)
- July 2015 (6)
- June 2015 (1)
- May 2015 (2)
- April 2015 (1)
- February 2015 (3)
- January 2015 (1)
- December 2014 (1)
- July 2010 (1)
- October 1991 (1)
- August 1989 (1)
- January 1988 (1)
- December 1983 (1)