Why is Carlsen Dominant? (A Theory)


Magnus Carlsen at the 2014 Sinquefield Cup, in Burning Boards by Glenn Kaino, Photo Courtesy WCHOF

Throughout the history of chess there have been very few individuals that have managed to dominate the chess world. Among them we can recall names such a Bobby Fischer, Garry Kasparov, and more recently Magnus Carlsen. Many will argue that Carlsen’s dominant reign is just starting and that there is nobody on the chess map that could possibly pose any problems in the near future. Carlsen himself said in one of his recent interviews that he had expected for a long time that somebody would stabilize above 2800, but nobody did. That stratospheric number is still one where the oxygen rarifies and not many can maintain a constant presence.  Caruana is the latest example, he skyrocketed to 2844 and immediately plummeted almost 50 points.

While some would attribute Carlsen’s dominance to his style of grinding down his opponents until they crack under pressure, I would like to go beyond that and try to understand why so many of his opponents lose positions in which you would expect the players to shake hands and sign the score sheets for a draw. I have seen this countless of times and the ability with which Carlsen manages to overcome these barriers is simply out of this world. Nobody at this time can do that as often as Carlsen does it, it seems to me that this type of game outcome has become a habit of both Carlsen and his opponents. But why?

My answer to this question lies behind a tool that has been used by sport psychologists to increase the potential of their athletes, it is called the anchor effect.  There is no doubt that between the mind and the body there is a powerful connection, therefore as long as we manage to build specifically crafted links between the two, we can enhance one’s potential and get the best results possible. The concept of anchoring was first brought into discussion by Dr. Ivan Pavlov’s notorious experiments on dogs, where he proved that he can condition the animals to salivate before they were shown any food just by ringing a bell. The same stimulus ->response type of behavior can be conditioned by sportsmen to perform at their best capability. Great performers often have a large number of conditioned stimulus that help them achieve full potential, and they allocate extra time to create and enhance these anchors. So what are the world champion’s secret weapons?

Carlsen’s positive anchors

The OJ


At the 2013 Sinquefield Cup, Kamsky vs. Carlsen, Photo Daaim Shabazz at chessdrum.net

One of Carlsen’s main anchor was, until not so long ago, his infamous orange juice. That juice placed in a water bottle was not only his beverage of choice, it was a powerful anchor that reminded him of the times he reached the pinnacle of his performance. Just by interacting with the bottle during the games, he reinforced that stimulus which triggered the desired response: not to lose focus and determination. The one important characteristics of anchors is that they fade in time, they lose their stimulus effect and therefore they become useless. In the case of Magnus, the orange juice has stopped giving him that sought reinforcement and therefore he started looking for stronger anchors.

The sunny escapes

In recent times we have seen the world champion always looking for a sunny escape before his important tournaments (as in the Hamptons before his trip to Saint Louis). I believe that he attached a great anchor to his travels, using that time to prepare mentally and remember how he felt when performing at his peak (stimulus). The response has been amazing, Carlsen has won almost every tournament he has participated in the last year, including three world championship titles and a few Grand Prix honors. Let’s see a few example when Carlsen uses his well-known technique.

Carlsen’s negative anchors

It is hard to find holes in the world champion’s shinny armor, nevertheless he has had a few moments in which he seemed to be a part of the mortal ranks. His performance in Norway Chess 2015 comes immediately to mind. He also had singular failings in the third round of 4 consecutive events in the 2014-2015 season! Carlsen has attached a very dangerous and negative anchor to these third round encounters. During these games he chose openings uncharacteristic to his style that landed him in very difficult situations where his resilience and competitive determination did not seem to be at the same level as he accustomed us to see. He himself had a good “laugh” with his twitter followers about this:
carlsen twitter







These negative anchors can be quite detrimental to one’s personal results, but if they are recognized then it will be much easier to eliminate them and even replace them with positive ones.

ChirilaImageHow you can build your own anchors

If you don’t have the option of consulting a professional sports psychologist, there are easy ways in which you can create your own powerful anchors. Here is an example:

1.       Choose and think of a distinctive stimulus, this will be your anchor and will trigger the desired response. This can be as simple as a hand squeeze, an eye roll, or whatever your imagination can come up with. The most important is that this anchor triggers only the specific response attached to it.

2.       Think of the last time you performed at your maximum potential, now think of how you felt during that time (mental & physical) and try to emulate those feelings.

3.       Now it’s time to launch the anchor, this will create the link between the state of mind and the personalized trigger.

4.       Now completely break the state you were in. Think of a completely neutral subject and completely detach yourself from the previous mental state.

5.       Repeat this process at least three times, this will install the anchor into your system. The more you will use the anchor with good results, the stronger the anchor will get. Whenever you feel good about your performance, launch the anchor and it will create the desired bond.

Now that you know an easy way to develop your own anchors, let’s see where that takes you. Athletes that create strong anchors will have a substantial advantage over those that don’t have this tool in their arsenal.

This one is for those professionals that want to test the anchor effect. If you manage to ever solve a specific problem, make sure you attach an anchor to it. This is one of the toughest practical problems I’ve ever attempted to solve, I guarantee the positive feeling you will get from finding the solution will be a powerful asset to your anchor arsenal. Good luck!


  1. How does one defeat an opponent whose very DNA is what he does – what he breathes? Richard Reti, the great theoretician and creator of one the most respected openings in chess, once said of Capablanca, another dominating player of his time, that chess was his [Capablanca’s]native tongue. I think that with Carlsen his specific dominating characteristics go beyond that. Carlsen has taken chess to another whole dimension. I don’t think today’s players are more talented that the players from the past, they are simply more theoretically prepared. They know what the players from the past know and then some. They stand on the shoulders of those magnificent players, many of whom were deep thinkers. They had to be. They lacked the practical wisdom of today’s players. They created the theory! And now, standing at the pinnacle of the past and the present is arguably the strongest player of all time – not merely a super grandmaster but a galactic player of the first magnitude. Before his chess playing days are over, we’ll need new adjectives to describe this force of nature. What makes Carlsen such an extraordinary player for our time is that he is surrounded by other great, talented and extremely strong players. Given the theoretical and technical knowledge that today’s top players possess it is really a minor miracle that any of them can be defeated, let alone dominated. This is also a testament to Carlsen’s dominance and his indefatigable will to win. How does he do it? Well, I think he has that extra ingredient or essence(whatever that is) that the other top players lack. And because he is so relatively young, much like Karpov in his time, he’ll dominate the chess world for the next 10 to 15 years until his chess powers begin to wane or until another player with Kasparov-like talent arrives on the scene and dethrones him. But until then, hail the Norwegian king.

Leave a Comment

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Announcements

  • US Chess Press